Remembering The Controversial Penalty That Almost Cost Dustin Johnson The 2016 US Open At Oakmont
Oakmont staging the US Open again conjures up memories of the last time it held the event, when Dustin Johnson had to survive a nervy rules controversy to lift the title


With the US Open returning to Oakmont you can't help but think back to the last time the event was held at the venue, when Dustin Johnson emerged with his maiden Major - but not without controversy.
Johnson had suffered several heartbreaking near misses in the Majors, and there threatened to be another one as he made his bid for a breakthrough at Oakmont.
He was racining away towards the US Open trophy but for most of his final round he had the spectre of a penalty hanging over his head from his ball moving on the fifth green.
Johnson called a rules official over after his ball moved before he addressed it with his putter, who told him to finish off the hole.
Only on the 12th hole, when Johnson was neck-and-neck with Shane Lowry, was he told he'd likely have a penalty, but the United States Golf Association would decide after his round.
For a player that had seen Majors slip from his grasp before, the next few holes most have been agony for Johnson, who would've feared that looming penalty might make all the difference.
However, Lowry fell away in the closing stretch and Johnson managed to complete a final round of 68 to win by four shots - which was then altered to a 69 and three-shot victory after being assessed that penalty.
Get the Golf Monthly Newsletter
Subscribe to the Golf Monthly newsletter to stay up to date with all the latest tour news, equipment news, reviews, head-to-heads and buyer’s guides from our team of experienced experts.
"I've had a lot of opportunites that I didn't quite get it done. So this one's definitely really sweet," said Johnson with a mixture of elation and relief after pocketing his first Major championship.
A stunning iron shot on the 18th helped him card a closing birdie and summed up the fact Johnson was just not going to be denied - even by the rules officials.
Perhaps Johnson was destined to win a Major championship this way, having had more than his fair share of close calls - starting when he let a three-shot lead at the 2010 US Open go after a horror start to the final round.
He also had a penalty assessed at the 2010 PGA Championship for grounding his club in one of Whistling Straits' unique bunkers, which cost him a place in a playoff.
And of course at the 2015 US Open he had a 12-foot putt on the last to win the title at Chambers Bay, only to three-putt and lose to Jordan Spieth by a shot.
Just 12 months later though he battled through a penalty issue to lift a fully deserved maiden Major victory.
2016 US OPen leaderboard
- -4 D Johnson
- -1 S Lowry
- -1 J Furyk
- -1 S Pirecy
- E S Garcia
- E B Grace
- +1 K Na
- +2 J Day
- +2 J Dufner
- +2 Z Johnson
- +2 D Summerhays

Paul Higham is a sports journalist with over 20 years of experience in covering most major sporting events for both Sky Sports and BBC Sport. He is currently freelance and covers the golf majors on the BBC Sport website. Highlights over the years include covering that epic Monday finish in the Ryder Cup at Celtic Manor and watching Rory McIlroy produce one of the most dominant Major wins at the 2011 US Open at Congressional. He also writes betting previews and still feels strangely proud of backing Danny Willett when he won the Masters in 2016 - Willett also praised his putting stroke during a media event before the Open at Hoylake. Favourite interviews he's conducted have been with McIlroy, Paul McGinley, Thomas Bjorn, Rickie Fowler and the enigma that is Victor Dubuisson. A big fan of watching any golf from any tour, sadly he spends more time writing about golf than playing these days with two young children, and as a big fair weather golfer claims playing in shorts is worth at least five shots. Being from Liverpool he loves the likes of Hoylake, Birkdale and the stretch of tracks along England's Golf Coast, but would say his favourite courses played are Kingsbarns and Portrush.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.
-
'The Worst Break Of His Life' - Watch JJ Spaun's Brutally Unlucky Bogey In The US Open Final Round
Spaun was on the second hole at Oakmont when a shot that would likely have stopped holeside was rejected over half the original distance back towards him
-
’If I Can’t Get Motivated To Get Up For An Open Championship At Home, Then I Don’t Know What Can Motivate Me' - Rory McIlroy Addresses Post-Masters Slump And Sets Sights On Royal Portrush
The five-time Major winner thinks next month's Open at Royal Portrush could be all he needs to reignite his motivation
-
'The Worst Break Of His Life' - Watch JJ Spaun's Brutally Unlucky Bogey In The US Open Final Round
Spaun was on the second hole at Oakmont when a shot that would likely have stopped holeside was rejected over half the original distance back towards him
-
’If I Can’t Get Motivated To Get Up For An Open Championship At Home, Then I Don’t Know What Can Motivate Me' - Rory McIlroy Addresses Post-Masters Slump And Sets Sights On Royal Portrush
The five-time Major winner thinks next month's Open at Royal Portrush could be all he needs to reignite his motivation
-
How Much The Winning Caddie Makes At The 2025 US Open
The prize pool for the US Open has stayed the same for the first time in five years but the winning caddie is still set to take home a huge chunk of the $4.3 million winning pot
-
The Unique Reason Why Viktor Hovland Switched Back To Nike Golf Shoes
Norwegian Viktor Hovland is starting to find form again after a disappointing 2024 and could his change of golf shoes be a small reason why?
-
From 'Get Off His Back' To 'He’s Showing His True Colors' - What Golf Fans Are Saying About Rory McIlroy's Recent Comments To The Media
Rory McIlroy opened up about why he's been skipping media after Saturday's third round at Oakmont - and golf fans had a lot to say
-
What Are Adam Scott's Career Earnings?
The 2013 Masters champion Adam Scott has been a household name on the PGA Tour since gaining his card in 2003, so how much money has he made?
-
LIV Golf Carlos Ortiz Said He ‘Deserved’ To Be At US Open… A Year On And He’s Contending To Win It
A year ago, Carlos Ortiz claimed he warranted a place in the US Open field - now, he's in the mix to take the title at Oakmont
-
‘I Knew That Could Have Been One Of The Negatives’ - Marc Leishman On Missing Majors After Joining LIV Golf
The Australian insists he has no regrets about joining LIV Golf, despite the US Open being his first Major appearance since 2022